As individual seasons go, 1998 is a favourite of mine.
The biggest storyline that year was the chase to break Roger Marris’ single-season home run record. Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa captivated fans through the summer and into the fall (yeah, yeah, I know). Their efforts put baseball back in the spotlight after the awful 1994 strike severely damaged MLB’s popularity.
Meanwhile, the ’98 Blue Jays were fun to watch for multiple reasons. They featured back-to-back Cy Young Award winners Pat Hentgen and Roger Clemens, with Clemens capturing his second straight award that season (yeah, yeah, I know).
The lineup consisted of young talent like Shannon Stewart, Shawn Green, Carlos Delgado and Jose Cruz Jr., as well as veteran all-stars like Jose Canseco (yeah, yeah, I know) and Tony Fernandez. You certainly can’t forget about 21-year-old Roy Halladay coming a few outs shy of a no-hitter or 40-year-old Dave Stieb making a comeback after a four-year absence.
The ’98 Jays weren’t a playoff team and it didn’t matter. There was only one wild card spot at the time and those fecking Yankees ultimately steamrolled their way to a World Series title. They still won 88 games which, as the record books show, was the highest win total of any Jays team between 1994-2014.
However, the ’98 Jays will not be remembered for what they did on the field. Instead, they’ll be remembered for who captained the ship that year: The infamous Tim Johnson.
Johnson was hired after the Blue Jays parted ways with Cito Gaston following a lousy 1997 season. The whole managerial search under General Manager Gord Ash was intriguing for me. It had been a long time since the team had to undertake such a task.
Names were circulating the zeitgeist. The two candidates I remember hearing regularly were Larry Bowa and Buck Martinez. I was also secretly hoping Ash would hire Paul Molitor to be a player-manager, similar to what Frank Robinson did with Cleveland in the 1970s.
Ultimately, Johnson was chosen and it seemed like every commentator and insider was over the moon about the hire.
Johnson was portrayed as someone who FINALLY had a chance to manage a big-league club. He paid his dues; seven seasons as a player in The Show – including 111 games with the Jays from 1978-79 – and nearly 20 years as a scout and coach. His reputation appeared to be spotless and full of glowing reviews.
Seemed like a perfect match.
The team performed well overall. However, things in the clubhouse were apparently strained. Perhaps the best example of this comes from Jerry Howarth’s 2019 autobiography, Hello Friends! The former radio play-by-play broadcaster provides an interesting anecdote involving Johnson and Dan Plesac. Won’t spoil it for you, but it illustrates Johnson’s flaws.
And then, there was his false military service.
Johnson claimed to be a Vietnam War veteran. He also used his experience overseas to motivate and coach his players.
But it was all a lie. Johnson never saw any action overseas. The closest he came was being part of the Reserves.
As noted by Craig Calcaterra in a 2016 article about Johnson for NBCSports.com, it was Roger Clemens – of all people – who inadvertently discovered his manager was a fraud.
Clemens was organizing a birthday gift for Johnson; a motorcycle, along with a helmet featuring the logo of his military unit. Johnson’s wife, Patty, was contacted to find out what unit her husband was part of. Unaware of her spouse’s deception, Patty simply stated that Johnson never went to Vietnam.
From there, a small flame turned into an inferno. Johnson would eventually admit he lied and apologized. The reaction was swift and intense.
Those same insiders and commentators who were jumping for joy when Johnson was hired were now demanding for his dismissal. He became a repulsive character and was repeatedly skewered for his actions. As a goofy 15-year-old, the whole saga was confusing for me.
“How can they love him a year ago and hate him now?” I would ask myself. “He lied. So what? We all lie and he apologized! He’s a good manager and the team played well. Let the man do his job.”
Clearly, I didn’t understand the severity of Johnson’s error, nor did I understand life in general (still don’t after all these years). From a current-day perspective, this was cancel culture well before the term ever existed.
While many wanted Johnson fired, Gord Ash felt his manager was remorseful, ready to move on and capable of managing the team. But pressure intensified and Johnson was fired midway through Spring Training the following year. Jim Fregosi replaced him.
Getting fired was an immediate punishment, but the penalty was long-standing.
To date, Johnson has not held any coaching or managerial positions with MLB teams or their minor league affiliates. He has remained in professional baseball though. According to Johnson’s Wikipedia page, he has managed a collection of teams in Mexico and independent ball.
Very little has been written about Johnson since his dishonourable departure. A few years after his firing, he was the subject of a news feature that portrayed him as a tortured individual; a good guy who made a gigantic mistake. Whether that won any sympathy depends on whoever watched it.
Tim Johnson won’t receive the same admiration that past skippers like Cito, Gibby and Bobby Cox get from the fanbase. If anything, the Blue Jays will continue to ignore his time with the club; sweeping him under the same rug as Roger Clemens’ two Cy Young-winning seasons.
To this day, it’s still wild how quickly Johnson went from a well-respected coach to a vile individual. A part of me feels sorry for him, but it must be noted that he brought it all on himself.
I hope someone makes a documentary about Tim Johnson. One of those 30 For 30 types of films. The Jays might choose to avoid Johnson, but his short tenure was too colourful and controversial to fall into vast obscurity. It’s a story that needs to be told!
And if someone does pursue a Tim Johnson documentary and needs a little help, feel free to reach out to me. 😎
ER
PS: Make sure to download your copy of SkyDome Syllables, a free e-book about the 2022 Blue Jays.